Happy New Year! We are open for dine-in, takeout and delivery!
Lunch Wednesday - Saturday
Specialty Sandwiches
All items served with a choice of side :
Sides
Black Eye Pea Salad
Chips
Fresh fruit (melon, grapes, pineapple, as per season)
Potato Salad
Side Salad : +1.5
Soup du Jour: +2.5
French Onion Dip
11.5
Roast beef with caramelized onions, melted provolone and horseradish mayo served hot on a hoagie with a side of au jus
Chicken Bacon Cheddar Ranch Melt
11.5
Mesquite grilled chicken, caramelized onions, melted cheddar and bacon, served on an onion roll with a side of ranch dressing
Castle Street Cubano
11.5
Succulent pork tenderloin with ham, melted provolone, dill pickle and Jester’s Sweet & Tangy Sauce
Spicy Southwestern Black Bean Burger
10.
Homemade black bean patty with avocado, melted provolone, lettuce, onion and tomato on an onion roll with chipotle mayo
B.L.E.S.T.
10.
Bacon, lettuce, egg salad and tomato on a buttery croissant
Mama's Lowcountry Shrimp Salad
10.
Shrimp tossed in a light lemon dill mayonnaise dressing with diced celery and sweet onion, served on a warm croissant with lettuce and tomato
Tuna / Chicken / Salad Melt
10.
Our homemade tuna, chicken or shrimp salad served open-face on a toasted English muffin with tomato, provolone and cheddar
Newcastle PImento Cheese Deluxe
10.
Our homemade sharp pimento cheese melted with caramelized onions, tomato and bacon served on toasted rye
Grown Up Grilled Cheese
10.
Provolone, American and cheddar cheeses with avocado, tomato and bacon on wheat
All Day Items
All items served with your choice of side
Sides
Black Eye Pea Salad
Chips
Fresh fruit (melon, grapes, pineapple, as per season)
Potato Salad
Side Salad : +1.5
Soup du Jour: +2.5
Quiche of the Day
9.
Ask your server for today’s selection of homemade veggie and meat quiches. Served with your choice of side and a pumpkin mini-muffin.
Strata
9.
Our homemade casserole layered with egg, sausage, cheddar cheese and hash browns. Served with your choice of side and a pumpkin mini-muffin.
Le Monsieur
10.
Our take on the classic Croque Monsieur: ham inside fluffy white bread with béchamel sauce, Dijon mustard and Swiss cheese melted on top
Avocado Toast
8.5
Half an avocado on Texas Toast with our homemade Castle Street Sauce.
Loaded Home Fries
8.5
Our delicious home fries topped with caramelized onion, diced avocado and tomato. (Not served with a side. Subject to availability as a lunch item)
Clubs
All items served with a choice of side
Sides
Black Eye Pea Salad
Chips
Fresh fruit (melon, grapes, pineapple, as per season)
Potato Salad
Side Salad : +1.5
Soup du Jour: +2.5
Rob's Club
10.
Turkey, bacon, avocado, provolone, lettuce, and tomato with honey mustard and mayo served on toasted white
Castle Street Club
10.
Roast beef, turkey, bacon, provolone, cheddar, lettuce and tomato with mayo and mustard served on toasted rye
American Club
10.
Ham, turkey and bacon with American cheese, lettuce and tomato with mayo served on toasted white
B.L.A.T.
9.5
Bacon, Lettuce, Avocado, Tomato served on Texas Toast with our Castle Sauce
Salads
Served with your choice of dressing on the side
Dressings:
12.
Bleu Cheese
Caesar
Lemon Dill Feta
Ranch
Raspberry Walnut Vinaigrette
Vidalia Onion Vinaigrette
White Balsamic Vinaigrette
Cobb Salad
12.
Mixed greens with turkey, provolone, hard-boiled egg, avocado, tomato, cucumber, red onion, carrot, bacon and bleu cheese crumbles
Shrimp Salad
12.
Our homemade shrimp salad on top of mixed greens with avocado, tomato, cucumber, red onion, carrot and hard-boiled egg
Mesquite Grilled Chicken Salad
12.
A boneless breast of mesquite grilled chicken on mixed greens, tomato, carrot, cucumber, red onion, shredded cheddar and jack cheese with a hard-boiled egg
Caesar Salad
9.5
Crisp romaine lettuce topped with blistered cherry tomatoes, banana peppers, red onions, croutons and homemade Caesar Dressing
Caesar Salad + Chicken or Shrimp
12.
Jester's Salad
8.5
Mixed greens with tomato, cucumber, red onion, carrot, mixed cheese and hard-boiled egg
Jester's Salad + scoop of tuna or chicken salad
11.
Junior Jesters Lunch
For our guests under 10 year old. Includes a small juice or milk. Served with fruit or chips
Grilled Cheese
5.5
Turkey & Cheese Sandwich
5.5
Ham & Cheese Sandwich
5.5
P B & J
5.5
Soup du Jour & Sides
Add to your experience
Side Salad
5.5
Spring greens, tomatoes, carrot, mixed cheese with your choice of dressing:
Bleu Cheese
Caesar
Lemon Dill Feta
Ranch
Raspberry Walnut Vinaigrette
Vidalia Onion Vinaigrette
White BalsamicVinaigrette
Soup du Jour
6.5
Ask your server about today's homemade selection
Fench Onion Soup
7.5
A classic!
Black Eye Pea Salad
3.5
Our homemade cold salad of black eye peas, onion, and red peppers in a vinaigrette
Fresh Fruit
3.5
A selection of ripe, seasonal fruit such as melons, pineapple, grapes
Potato Salad
3.5
Our homemade potato salad with light mayo and green onions
Chips
1.5
Crunchy kettle-style potato chips
Special Side
Please ask your server about today's special side
Coffee, Tea, Etc.
Locally Brewed Coffee - Hot or Iced
2.5
Iced Tea (Sweet or Unsweet)
2.
Hot Tea
2.
Your choice of black, green or herbal tea
Uptown
2.5
- ½ sweet tea, ½ lemonade
Downtown
2.5
- ½ unsweet tea, ½ lemonade
Lemonade
2.5
(Refill: +1.)
Perrier
2.5
Soft Drinks
2.
- Pepsi / Diet Pepsi
- Cheerwine / Diet Cheerwine
- 7-Up / Diet 7-Up
- Ginger Ale
- Sundrop
Juice
1.5 / 2.
- Orange
- Cranberry
- Cran / Orange
Milk
2.
Chocolate Milk
2.5
Hot Chocolate
3.
Wine & Beer
Sparkling Wine
7. / 28.
Proa Brut sparkling wine by the glass or by the bottle
Sparkling + Carafe of Juice
30.
A bottle of Proa Brut Sparkling plus a carafe of orange, peach or cranberry
Mimosa
9.
- Sparkling wine + orange juice
Just Peachy
9.
- Sparkling wine + peach juice
Poinsettia
9.
- Sparkling wine + cranberry juice
Sparkling Rosato
7. / 28.
Cantine Elvio Tintero. Delightfully fizzy and slightly sweet, but dry, Italian-style rosé.
Pinot Grigio
7. / 28.
Cantine Aurora Corte Ballo. Flowery nose, crisp, dry, clean flavor and refreshing finish.
Sauvignon Blanc
7. / 28.
La Galope. A light golden straw color, with notes of fresh citrus and grapefruit.
Chardonnay
7. / 28.
La Galope. A French-style unoaked chardonnay, lightly buttered, with notes of honey and lemon.
Rosé
7. / 28.
Masciarelli Colline Teatino. A pale pink Italian rosato, with a fruity taste and a citrus rind finish.
Cabernet Sauvignon
8. / 32.
Liberty School. Dark fruit, savory herbs and clean bright acidity finish with sweet oak.
Flying Embers Hard Kombucha
5.
Fresh dark cherry flavors, finishes clean with a bright twist of lime spritz. Brewed with Live Probiotics and Adaptogen Root Blend of Ginger and Turmeric.
Paulaner Salvator Doppelbock Lager
5.
This beer very food-friendly and reminiscent of toasted bread.
Dragon's Milk White Stout
5.5
A full flavored White Stout with strong notes of vanilla, cocoa, coffee roast, and oak.
Southern Pines Nav Mexican Lager
5.5
A perfect accompaniment to breakfast, brunch or lunch.
Southern Pines Misty Haze
5.5
This light-bodied, hazy pale ale was brewed with oats, wheat, and barley, before giving it a luscious amount of Mosaic, Citra, and Centennial hops.
Coffee is for Closers
5.
A smooth, semi-sweet porter brewed with cold-pressed Muddy Dog Roasting Co. Sumatra and Larry's Coffee “Bean Martin” blend.
Desserts
Selections vary daily.
Walnut Oreo Fudge Brownie
4.
Walnut Oreo Fudge Brownie à la mode
5.5
Key Lime Cutie Pie
5.
Homemade individual key lime pie
Cheesecake
6.
Ask your sever about our seasonal selection
Coffee Cake
4.
Irish Coffee
5.5
Wednesday Night Family Meal
A terrific heat and eat meal that serves 4. Selections vary weekly. Pre-order by Tuesdays at noon for pickup Wednesday between 4-6 pm.
Main Course
50.
Menu items may contain or come into contact with wheat, eggs, peanuts, tree nuts and milk. No substitutions, please.
NEWS
WOW! Now you can order right from our website for takeout or delivery powered by ChowNow!